Pros and Cons of a Multi-Ecommerce Fulfillment Center Approach

thumbnail

Without a doubt, Amazon is king of multiple ecommerce satisfaction center processing and shipping. Amazon is a risk to lots of ecommerce organisations in regards to product cost, delivering expense and speed to deliver orders. Amazon’s sales and satisfaction center growth is not going to diminish anytime quickly. Nor will UPS and FedEx rate walkings cease.

A multi-FC strategy isn’t right for each business due to the fact that of the added expenses, inventory required and managing a 2nd remote center. Coming to the right choice for your company takes in-depth evaluation. Here are 11 aspects to consider at the same time.

Determine Strategic Objectives

What is your present shipment scenario in terms of cost and time to consumer? How do you wish to see improvement? If management’s goal is to be one day ground from 95% of your consumers, examine your existing shipping information to determine how many areas will get you there.

Building Requirements

To identify your future structure requirements, these 15 considerations will assist in the choice process. Use a business genuine estate broker that has a subscription to one of the nationwide information bases of all existing buildings and build to suit sites in the markets.

Staffing and Labor Cost Study

We utilize the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ (BLS) detailed labor and work information to aid in predicting payroll for proposed sites and organizations. Then we do the “boots on the ground” research study needed for a market, visit and trip other storage facility operators to understand the possible marketplace. BLS data can just offer part of the details required.

Incoming Freight from Vendors

Examine how potential new website areas and your existing ecommerce satisfaction center will affect this expenditure. Would receiving in more than one location reduction costs as they’re closer to the entry point into your supply chain? To evaluate this, you require historical inbound freight expenses for a year; the coming from city or port of entry; and the variety of deliveries from all vendors and the weight and expense of each. From here you can examine which places have the biggest effect on this expenditure.

Outbound Shipping Costs

Evaluate how prospective brand-new site places and existing area(s) will impact this expenditure. The historic data required is the detailed last 12 months or last calendar year of each shipment, the weight and shipping costs, carrier service level and the carrier zone this resulted in. For the potential brand-new areas, determine how the expense, zone shipped and transit time are positively impacted.

Inventory Required

The boost in inventory required is a major consideration. Will all products be reproduced in all area? Will finest sellers be in all centers and sluggish or average sellers just in one ecommerce fulfillment? Would ship-alone, heavy products be in one center only?

Capital Expenses and One-Time Costs

These expenses will differ by prospective sites, consisting of the center’s build-out expenses, setup of racking, material handling devices (MHE) and conveyance devices and transport of item.

Stock Increase

Just how much extra stock is required to fill customer orders from several centers? Our experience is that a 2nd fulfillment center adds 30% or more stock dollars compared to a single center.

Start-Up and Lost Productivity

There is always a start-up duration with lower performance with the brand-new center, employees, systems and MHE use. Typically there is higher-than-expected worker turnover. Strategy the ramp up realistically over the preliminary months– 6 months or longer for some centers.

System Functionality Required

Do your systems have the needed functionality to control inventory and fill orders from several areas? Exist company rules to assign consumers to a particular ecommerce satisfaction center, and to assign stock based on orders? Can service rules about back ordered items be set up to not fill from two locations? Can your product planning and acquiring systems record sales by place?

Other Factors

These consist of organisation incentives, state and county sales taxes and inventory tax if applicable.

Consider third-party logistics as a choice

Consider utilizing a 3PL partner if adding employees and spending capital to open additional satisfaction centers is not cost reasonable. This will have considerably lower start-up expenses and be faster to execute. Selection and standup can be done in six months vs. 12 months for renting an existing building, or more than two years for a new facility (website choice and build to match). This prior post has more info on this consideration.

Providing outcomes

High-level comparative analysis of choices considered: Prepare a side-by-side contrast of the pros/cons of the various choices on as couple of spreadsheets tabs as possible. Examples include 3PL vs. an owned or rented center, and the product techniques you’re suggesting.

This type of study produces a great deal of information and supporting data. To provide the key findings, we recommend summarizing crucial analyses:

Brian Barry is President of F. Curtis Barry & & Company

For numerous business, having more than one ecommerce satisfaction center or even multiple areas– either internally handled or through 3PL partners– is the finest long-term method for controlling shipping expenses and shortening delivery time to customer.

Danger analysis of alternatives and areas thought about: Evaluate all the threats by tactical option for each area. Include things like wage rate and sales tax differences, and whether it’s located in a right-to-work state. Price quote the possible loss and possibility of each threat. Likewise think about the possibility of hold-ups in building and construction or leasing, unintended expenses and excessive employee turnover.

Top-level comparative analysis of site areas: As above, prepare a side-by-side comparison of the finest websites. Program the boost or decrease of outbound and incoming freight; labor market viability and work; staffing salaries, hourly wages and advantages; triple net tenancy costs; facility expenses for construct out, racking, conveyance and systems; and the freight cost to move stock.


Amazon is a threat to numerous ecommerce organisations in terms of item cost, delivering cost and speed to deliver orders. Would receiving in more than one place decline costs as they’re closer to the entry point into your supply chain? To analyze this, you need historic inbound freight expenses for a year; the coming from city or port of entry; and the number of shipments from all suppliers and the weight and cost of each. The historical information required is the detailed last 12 months or last calendar year of each delivery, the weight and shipping expenses, provider service level and the provider zone this resulted in. If including staff members and spending capital to open additional fulfillment centers is not cost justifiable, consider using a 3PL partner.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top